Testosterone Therapy (TRT) in Men With Untreated Prostate Cancer (PrCa)
Testosterone therapy has been shown to have a number of beneficial effects in men with testosterone deficiency, including improvement in symptoms of fatigue, decreased libido and sexual performance. However, a major concern has been that increased serum testosterone may cause growth of prostate cancer. This concern is based on the observations that androgen deprivation causes PrCa regression as reflected by decreased serum PSA, and that normalization of serum T in androgen deprived men causes an increase in PSA. Historically there has been an absolute prohibition against the use of TRT in men with any prior history of PrCa.
However, recent literature has called this traditional paradigm into question. A small series of retrospective studies have reported benign outcomes in men who underwent TRT following definitive treatment of localized PrCa. Of these studies 3, with a total population of 74 men, were of men with testosterone deprivation (TD) who had undergone radical prostatectomy for PrCa. None of the participants had biochemical recurrence with follow-up as long as 12 years. Another study reported no biochemical recurrence in 31 men who underwent TRT for a median of 4.5 years following brachytherapy for localized PrCa.
One explanation for the lack of biochemical recurrence is that men were cured of PrCa. Another is that a higher serum T concentration does not necessarily lead to greater PrCa growth. A global pooled collaborative analysis of 18 longitudinal studies of sex hormones and PrCa comprised of 3,886 men with PrCa and 6,438 age matched controls found no relationship between endogenous serum androgen concentrations and PrCa. In another study intraprostatic T and DHT concentrations were unchanged after 6 months of TRT in men with TD despite large changes in serum T concentrations. A saturation model has been proposed to account for the substantial prostatic changes observed with institution or cessation of androgen deprivation therapy and the relative indifference of prostate tissue to changes in serum T above the near castrate range.
Without large, randomized, long-term studies of TRT in men with TD it remains an unanswered question whether TRT may cause greater PrCa growth in this cohort. This question is of particular relevance to the increasing number of men who currently elect active surveillance for newly diagnosed PrCa, some of whom are symptomatic from T deficiency and desirous of TRT.
As new data have suggested a less risky relationship between T and PrCa than previously assumed, we and others have become more open to the practice of offering TRT to men with a history of PrCa. A decrease in PSA was noted in an elderly man who received TRT during PrCa surveillance. In this study they report on prostate biopsy and PSA results in a group of symptomatic T deficient men who received TRT while undergoing active surveillance for untreated PrCa. The emergence of serial prostate biopsies as a critical component of active surveillance protocols in men with PrCa presents a new and unique opportunity to evaluate the effect of TRT on PrCa growth.
Morgentaler A, Lipshultz LI, Bennett R, Sweeney M, Avila D, Jr., Khera M. Testosterone Therapy in Men With Untreated Prostate Cancer. J Urol. Testosterone therapy in men with untreated prostat... [J Urol. 2011] - PubMed result
PURPOSE: A history of prostate cancer has been a longstanding contraindication to the use of testosterone therapy due to the belief that higher serum testosterone causes more rapid prostate cancer growth. Recent evidence has called this paradigm into question. In this study we investigate the effect of testosterone therapy in men with untreated prostate cancer.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We report the results of prostate biopsies, serum prostate specific antigen and prostate volume in symptomatic testosterone deficient cases receiving testosterone therapy while undergoing active surveillance for prostate cancer.
RESULTS: A total of 13 symptomatic testosterone deficient men with untreated prostate cancer received testosterone therapy for a median of 2.5 years (range 1.0 to 8.1). Mean age was 58.8 years. Gleason score at initial biopsy was 6 in 12 men and 7 in 1. Mean serum concentration of total testosterone increased from 238 to 664 ng/dl (p <0.001). Mean prostate specific antigen did not change with testosterone therapy (5.5 +/- 6.4 vs 3.6 +/- 2.6 ng/ml, p = 0.29). Prostate volume was unchanged. Mean number of follow-up biopsies was 2. No cancer was found in 54% of followup biopsies. Biopsies in 2 men suggested upgrading, and subsequent biopsies in 1 and radical prostatectomy in another indicated no progression. No local prostate cancer progression or distant disease was observed.
CONCLUSIONS: Testosterone therapy in men with untreated prostate cancer was not associated with prostate cancer progression in the short to medium term. These results are consistent with the saturation model, ie maximal prostate cancer growth is achieved at low androgen concentrations. The longstanding prohibition against testosterone therapy in men with untreated or low risk prostate cancer or treated prostate cancer without evidence of metastatic or recurrent disease merits reevaluation.
Testosterone therapy has been shown to have a number of beneficial effects in men with testosterone deficiency, including improvement in symptoms of fatigue, decreased libido and sexual performance. However, a major concern has been that increased serum testosterone may cause growth of prostate cancer. This concern is based on the observations that androgen deprivation causes PrCa regression as reflected by decreased serum PSA, and that normalization of serum T in androgen deprived men causes an increase in PSA. Historically there has been an absolute prohibition against the use of TRT in men with any prior history of PrCa.
However, recent literature has called this traditional paradigm into question. A small series of retrospective studies have reported benign outcomes in men who underwent TRT following definitive treatment of localized PrCa. Of these studies 3, with a total population of 74 men, were of men with testosterone deprivation (TD) who had undergone radical prostatectomy for PrCa. None of the participants had biochemical recurrence with follow-up as long as 12 years. Another study reported no biochemical recurrence in 31 men who underwent TRT for a median of 4.5 years following brachytherapy for localized PrCa.
One explanation for the lack of biochemical recurrence is that men were cured of PrCa. Another is that a higher serum T concentration does not necessarily lead to greater PrCa growth. A global pooled collaborative analysis of 18 longitudinal studies of sex hormones and PrCa comprised of 3,886 men with PrCa and 6,438 age matched controls found no relationship between endogenous serum androgen concentrations and PrCa. In another study intraprostatic T and DHT concentrations were unchanged after 6 months of TRT in men with TD despite large changes in serum T concentrations. A saturation model has been proposed to account for the substantial prostatic changes observed with institution or cessation of androgen deprivation therapy and the relative indifference of prostate tissue to changes in serum T above the near castrate range.
Without large, randomized, long-term studies of TRT in men with TD it remains an unanswered question whether TRT may cause greater PrCa growth in this cohort. This question is of particular relevance to the increasing number of men who currently elect active surveillance for newly diagnosed PrCa, some of whom are symptomatic from T deficiency and desirous of TRT.
As new data have suggested a less risky relationship between T and PrCa than previously assumed, we and others have become more open to the practice of offering TRT to men with a history of PrCa. A decrease in PSA was noted in an elderly man who received TRT during PrCa surveillance. In this study they report on prostate biopsy and PSA results in a group of symptomatic T deficient men who received TRT while undergoing active surveillance for untreated PrCa. The emergence of serial prostate biopsies as a critical component of active surveillance protocols in men with PrCa presents a new and unique opportunity to evaluate the effect of TRT on PrCa growth.
Morgentaler A, Lipshultz LI, Bennett R, Sweeney M, Avila D, Jr., Khera M. Testosterone Therapy in Men With Untreated Prostate Cancer. J Urol. Testosterone therapy in men with untreated prostat... [J Urol. 2011] - PubMed result
PURPOSE: A history of prostate cancer has been a longstanding contraindication to the use of testosterone therapy due to the belief that higher serum testosterone causes more rapid prostate cancer growth. Recent evidence has called this paradigm into question. In this study we investigate the effect of testosterone therapy in men with untreated prostate cancer.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We report the results of prostate biopsies, serum prostate specific antigen and prostate volume in symptomatic testosterone deficient cases receiving testosterone therapy while undergoing active surveillance for prostate cancer.
RESULTS: A total of 13 symptomatic testosterone deficient men with untreated prostate cancer received testosterone therapy for a median of 2.5 years (range 1.0 to 8.1). Mean age was 58.8 years. Gleason score at initial biopsy was 6 in 12 men and 7 in 1. Mean serum concentration of total testosterone increased from 238 to 664 ng/dl (p <0.001). Mean prostate specific antigen did not change with testosterone therapy (5.5 +/- 6.4 vs 3.6 +/- 2.6 ng/ml, p = 0.29). Prostate volume was unchanged. Mean number of follow-up biopsies was 2. No cancer was found in 54% of followup biopsies. Biopsies in 2 men suggested upgrading, and subsequent biopsies in 1 and radical prostatectomy in another indicated no progression. No local prostate cancer progression or distant disease was observed.
CONCLUSIONS: Testosterone therapy in men with untreated prostate cancer was not associated with prostate cancer progression in the short to medium term. These results are consistent with the saturation model, ie maximal prostate cancer growth is achieved at low androgen concentrations. The longstanding prohibition against testosterone therapy in men with untreated or low risk prostate cancer or treated prostate cancer without evidence of metastatic or recurrent disease merits reevaluation.