My point is that the vast majority on this forum don't look good, no matter what their individual dosing protocol is, so you almost always see "small" guys advocating for small or big test bases.
280 lbs @ 20% bf "big" isn't even comparable to IFBB contest ready big. And seriously, if you look through the pic thread, none of the "big" guys look good. Each individual muscle group blends together, they have big waists, and it doesn't seem to matter how lean they get. Further, bone structure and the genetic muscle belly shape we're all born with play a huge role. A guy with wide hips and narrow shoulders will never look good, regardless of gear usage or training.
If someone wants to weigh 280 lbs and look like a marshmallow, this is a great place for advice. Look at all of the asinine responses to actual science. People post studies or break downs from chemists or other PHD's, and the vast majority of responses are "Lol, that dude is small. Why should I listen to him?" which is hilariously stupid.
How many IFBB pros are posting here? The same people getting bad advice on this forum can hire a coach who trains IFBB pros, has a PHD, and knows what they're talking about.
This forum is a decent (not great) resource for newbies looking to mitigate some risk when learning, but alot of the time the more experienced old heads are the guys advocating dangerous practices, simply because they didn't know any better and they happened to get away with it.
Someone will know if they're IFBB capable after their first cycle.
If someone is smart, they're going to use this forum to judge sources, but little else. Delve into the literature, gain a sound scientific understanding of these compounds and their impact on the body, and hire a coach who works with actual pros, after taking dieting and training seriously enough to get very close to their genetic limit while remaining natty. Granted, it's a fun place to BS with others who are like-minded in some manner, but it should not be treated as a resource for much outside of source validation.