Not really a peanut butter alternative but that PB2 stuff is pretty legit. Makes mixing it into things way easier. Might be a little thinner than the cold molasses OP is making lol. I’ve actually taken a dinner my wife made and blended it once. Chicken, potatoes, milk, cheese, sour cream, salt and pepper…blended it up and then microwaved it. It was like drinking a thick soup. Actually wasn’t that bad. I was so fucking tired of chicken I needed a way to get it down. Wife was in prep for her bikini comp so all we fucking had was plain ass chicken everyday.