marianco
Doctor of Medicine
Propecia and Adrenal Fatigue
I wish the units were included to help translate them into units commonly used in the U.S.
Often I wonder how men who previously used Propecia developed seemingly permanent problems from it despite stopping it. Unless Propecia causes some genetic damage (and there is no evidence of this), it is very unlikely that Propecia is the cause. I would look to other persistent problems instead that may have been overlooked.
One possible scenario: a man who is living a stressful life realizes he is losing hair. Hair loss is a possible consequence of stress alone - for example, by causing a loss of zinc. The man takes Propecia to try to help reduce the hair loss. Along the way, he developes fatigue, loss of libido, erectile disturbance, depression or other mood problems. The problem is blamed on Propecia. Propecia is stopped. The problems persist. What happened? A possible answer is that the stressful life, which caused the hair loss, also caused adrenal fatigue - which can cause all of the symptoms described.
Diagnosising adrenal fatigue via blood tests is difficult because it is based on looking at small deviations from the mean. The diagnosis is helped by history and physical exam. On physical exam, often the blood pressure is low - or blood pressure drops between the sitting and standing measurements. There may be sensitivity to sunlight, weakness of pupillary constriction to light. Other historical clues include sugar or salt cravings, craving for chocolate, fatigue and sleepiness in the afternoon, difficulty in falling asleep at night, a desire to sleep most of the time, increased energy at night, etc.
Blood test clues include:
1. Low normal cortisol
2. Low normal DHEA-s
3. Low normal progesterone
4. Low normal blood sugar
5. Low sodium
6. Low potassium
7. high normal to high albumin
8. high cholesterol
The best test for adrenal fatigue is a saliva test with cortisol at four times in a day, and DHEA-s at least twice in a day.
James Wilson's book "Adrenal Fatigue" is a good place to start for information.
One mistake I see many people make when doing hormone balancing is to treat thyroid deficiency simultaneously with adrenal fatigue. The problem is that thyroid hormone forces the adrenal glands to increase output. Increasing output is exactly what the adrenal glands have a problem doing. The result is a worsening of adrenal fatigue and the patient does not get better.
Interestingly, in some people, treating adrenal fatigue (such as with progesterone and hydrocortisone), often results in a return of morning erections even when testosterone is as low as 170 (300-850).
TylerR said:i have fatique, lack of morning erections, weak erections, inability to orgasm, absolutely no libido. lack of emotions, my problems appear to be from the use propecia like a few others here, i have not taken any other medications. my urologist has also said i have also have an enlarged prostate, i assume its from the high estrogens in my system. i'm in my early 30's height 5feet 7" weigh 160. i have been off propecia for 2 yrs yet the symptoms still persist, having taken it for 8 months.
gonadal:
testosterone = 465 range 250-850
free testosterone = 14 range 9.3-26.5
estradiol = 45 range <54
dht = 36 range 30-85
adrenal:
progesterone = 2.6 range <4.0
cortisol = 399 range < 175 - 685 (done in the morning)
dhea-s = 6.8 range 5.2 - 14.2
thyroid:
tsh = 1.3 range 0.47 - 4.2
free t3 = 4.3 range 4.0 - 6.8
pancreatic:
glucose fasting = 4.7 range 3.3 - 6.0
liver panel:
albumin = 46 range 35 - 50
lipids:
cholesterol = 4.67 range 2.0 - 4.59
I wish the units were included to help translate them into units commonly used in the U.S.
Often I wonder how men who previously used Propecia developed seemingly permanent problems from it despite stopping it. Unless Propecia causes some genetic damage (and there is no evidence of this), it is very unlikely that Propecia is the cause. I would look to other persistent problems instead that may have been overlooked.
One possible scenario: a man who is living a stressful life realizes he is losing hair. Hair loss is a possible consequence of stress alone - for example, by causing a loss of zinc. The man takes Propecia to try to help reduce the hair loss. Along the way, he developes fatigue, loss of libido, erectile disturbance, depression or other mood problems. The problem is blamed on Propecia. Propecia is stopped. The problems persist. What happened? A possible answer is that the stressful life, which caused the hair loss, also caused adrenal fatigue - which can cause all of the symptoms described.
Diagnosising adrenal fatigue via blood tests is difficult because it is based on looking at small deviations from the mean. The diagnosis is helped by history and physical exam. On physical exam, often the blood pressure is low - or blood pressure drops between the sitting and standing measurements. There may be sensitivity to sunlight, weakness of pupillary constriction to light. Other historical clues include sugar or salt cravings, craving for chocolate, fatigue and sleepiness in the afternoon, difficulty in falling asleep at night, a desire to sleep most of the time, increased energy at night, etc.
Blood test clues include:
1. Low normal cortisol
2. Low normal DHEA-s
3. Low normal progesterone
4. Low normal blood sugar
5. Low sodium
6. Low potassium
7. high normal to high albumin
8. high cholesterol
The best test for adrenal fatigue is a saliva test with cortisol at four times in a day, and DHEA-s at least twice in a day.
James Wilson's book "Adrenal Fatigue" is a good place to start for information.
One mistake I see many people make when doing hormone balancing is to treat thyroid deficiency simultaneously with adrenal fatigue. The problem is that thyroid hormone forces the adrenal glands to increase output. Increasing output is exactly what the adrenal glands have a problem doing. The result is a worsening of adrenal fatigue and the patient does not get better.
Interestingly, in some people, treating adrenal fatigue (such as with progesterone and hydrocortisone), often results in a return of morning erections even when testosterone is as low as 170 (300-850).