No Mortality Differences Among Localized Prostate Cancer Treatments
Compared with active monitoring, radical treatment of localized prostate cancer does not improve disease-specific or overall survival at 10 years, a multicenter UK trial in Health Technology Assessment found. Active monitoring, radical prostatectomy and radical radiotherapy in PSA-detected clinically localised prostate cancer: the ProtecT three-arm RCT - NCBI Bookshelf
After prostate-specific antigen testing, 1643 men with localized prostate cancer were randomized to receive active monitoring, radical prostatectomy, or radical radiotherapy.
No statistically significant differences occurred regardless of treatment among 17 men who died of prostate cancer and 169 who died of other causes. At a 10-year median follow-up, almost all the men in each group were alive. Radical treatment, however, reduced disease progression by approximately 50% compared with active monitoring; 55% of men receiving active monitoring eventually received radical treatment.
Surgery resulted in greater urinary incontinence and erectile symptoms, and radiotherapy caused erectile and bowel symptoms. Men in the active monitoring group had a general decline in their urinary and sexual function with age and subsequent radical treatments. Quality of life, anxiety, and depression were similar among all groups. The study will observe the men for a median of 15 years total to determine the treatments’ longer-term effects.
Slomski A. No Mortality Differences Among Localized Prostate Cancer Treatments. JAMA. 2020;324(16):1599. No Mortality Differences Among Localized Prostate Cancer Treatments
Compared with active monitoring, radical treatment of localized prostate cancer does not improve disease-specific or overall survival at 10 years, a multicenter UK trial in Health Technology Assessment found. Active monitoring, radical prostatectomy and radical radiotherapy in PSA-detected clinically localised prostate cancer: the ProtecT three-arm RCT - NCBI Bookshelf
After prostate-specific antigen testing, 1643 men with localized prostate cancer were randomized to receive active monitoring, radical prostatectomy, or radical radiotherapy.
No statistically significant differences occurred regardless of treatment among 17 men who died of prostate cancer and 169 who died of other causes. At a 10-year median follow-up, almost all the men in each group were alive. Radical treatment, however, reduced disease progression by approximately 50% compared with active monitoring; 55% of men receiving active monitoring eventually received radical treatment.
Surgery resulted in greater urinary incontinence and erectile symptoms, and radiotherapy caused erectile and bowel symptoms. Men in the active monitoring group had a general decline in their urinary and sexual function with age and subsequent radical treatments. Quality of life, anxiety, and depression were similar among all groups. The study will observe the men for a median of 15 years total to determine the treatments’ longer-term effects.
Slomski A. No Mortality Differences Among Localized Prostate Cancer Treatments. JAMA. 2020;324(16):1599. No Mortality Differences Among Localized Prostate Cancer Treatments