Ranking the greatest of all time in bodybuilding

[Biggerarms22]

This is my top 16 if they all stepped on stage in their best shape today-

1. Ronnie coleman.
2. Phil heath.
3. Dorian Yates.
4. Kai Greene.
5. Jay cutler.
6. Ramy.
7. Nassar.
8. Flex wheeler.
9. Dexter Jackson.
10. Markus Ruhl.
11. Shawn Rhoden.
12. Brandon Curry.
13. Hadi Choopan.
14. Roelly Winkler.
15. Kevin levrone
16. Dennis Wolf.
T16. Branch Warren.
T16. Lee priest.
T16. Shawn Ray.
T16. Mike mentzer.

What's your top?

 

[Methyl Mike]

This is my top 16 if they all stepped on stage in their best shape today-

1. Ronnie coleman.
2. Phil heath.
3. Dorian Yates.
4. Kai Greene.
5. Jay cutler.
6. Ramy.
7. Nassar.
8. Flex wheeler.
9. Dexter Jackson.
10. Markus Ruhl.
11. Shawn Rhoden.
12. Brandon Curry.
13. Hadi Choopan.
14. Roelly Winkler.
15. Kevin levrone
16. Dennis Wolf.
T16. Branch Warren.
T16. Lee priest.
T16. Shawn Ray.
T16. Mike mentzer.

What's your top?

I don't think Ronnie could beat Yates. We never saw them onstage both at their peak but from what Dorian has said in interviews since he was already the biggest guy he overdieted on purpose so the smaller guys couldn't catch him with conditioning. When Ronnie hit his stride let's assume Yates is still healthy with 2 whole arms he would have noticed another big guy who could match his size so he would have come in much.bigger. Dorian is not being beaten from the side or the back and Olympia judges tend to reward conditioning which I don't think Ronnies track record says he would have been spot on consistently. I mean let's see the years Ronnie looked good were 98,99,2005 the rest he looked only soso and 2002 2004 and 2006 complete.shit. Dorian was far more consistent.

The rest of the list Ruhl definitely beats Ramy and I would place Choopan right behind Markus.
The rest of your list is pretty cringeworthy.

 

[bigpoppachump2]

Seeing Kai in 4th gives me major discomfort lol

 

[bigpoppachump2]

I feel that switching Kai and Lee Priest would make this list a little more respectable

 

[Methyl Mike]

I feel that switching Kai and Lee Priest would make this list a little more respectable

Ummm it needs a lot of work.

 

[FR0Z3N_B0MB3RRR]

1 Craig Golias
2 Steve Reeves
3 Flex Wheeler
4 Bob Paris
5 Serge Nubret
6 Arnold Schwarzenegger
7 Ronnie Coleman 1998
8 Milos Sarcev
9 Franco Columbu
10 Shawn Ray
11 Chris Bumstead
12 Zyzz
13 Giampietro Diedhiou
14 Mike O Hearn
15 Riccardo Croci
16 Berry De Mey
17 Andrei Deiu