Re: Weight-Loss/Obesity
[The very company making the product EMPLOYS the authors. It sounds very similar to the product by Gelesis - Gelesis | About Gelesis .]
Experimental Drink Could Help Dieters Feel Full
Medical News: Experimental Drink Could Help Dieters Feel Full - in Primary Care, Obesity from MedPage Today
With the growing epidemic of obesity, Dutch researchers may have come up with a way for people to stick to their diets and lose weight -- an experimental meal replacement drink that seems to reduce hunger pangs and help dieters feel full longer.
A study conducted among 23 volunteers found that the drink reduced their hunger by as much as 30%, five hours (P< 0.001) after drinking it, reported Harry Peters, a manager-scientist of Unilever Research & Development in Vlaardingen, the Netherlands, and colleagues.
The secret ingredient: a strongly gelling dietary fiber called alginate.
"The drink was designed in such a way that it only gels under gastric conditions and not in the product before consumption," Peters and co-authors explained online in the journalObesity. They theorized that a drink of this kind "would dose-dependently decrease hunger responses at relatively low alginate levels."
A drink containing the gelling fiber that was palatable and able to delay the return of hunger could potentially increase consumer satisfaction with weight control programs and low-calorie food products, and thus encourage long-term compliance, the Dutch team suggested.
"Satiety feelings on a meal-to-meal basis are partly determined by gastrointestinal (GI) stimuli," they wrote. "One way to increase satiety is by formation of gels within the stomach. However, the viscosity of drinks needs to be high to increase satiety, and this may reduce consumer acceptance for many (e.g., fluid) types of products."
But producing a palatable drink based on post-consumption gelatin stimulated by gastric conditions might therefore be a preferred option, they suggested.
So they whipped up an experimental low-viscosity breakfast drink -- a prototype ready-to-drink chocolate-flavored meal replacement shake containing 190 calories in 325 ml (around 10 oz) -- using two concentrations of alginate (0.6% and 0.8%) designed to turn into a satiating gel only after it was consumed. Controls consumed the shake without added alginate.
A group of healthy volunteers were recruited from around the Unilever research site in Vlaardingen; 23 completed the study.
The volunteers (mean age around 53) consumed the drink containing various levels of alginate in place of a meal and reported their levels of hunger and fullness over the next five hours.
Volunteers who had the highest level of alginate in their drinks reported less hunger than the control group, with both "hunger" and "fullness" reduced robustly (20% and 34% lower area under the curve, respectively) with 0.8% alginate (both P<0.001, analysis of covariance). This effect was consistent across all six appetite scales used, Peters and co-authors wrote.
Most effects were also significant with 0.6% alginate, and a clear dose-response was observed.
"Although self-reported decreases in hunger are robustly reported in this study, further studies are needed to establish its implications for food intake, compliance to weight-loss programs, and long-term effects on weight loss or weight maintenance," Peters and colleagues concluded.
Peters HP, Koppert RJ, Boers HM, et al. Dose-Dependent Suppression of Hunger by a Specific Alginate in a Low-Viscosity Drink Formulation. Obesity (Silver Spring). Dose-Dependent Suppression of Hunger by a Specific... [Obesity (Silver Spring). 2011] - PubMed result
Addition of specific types of alginates to drinks can enhance postmeal suppression of hunger, by forming strong gastric gels in the presence of calcium. However, some recent studies have not demonstrated an effect of alginate/calcium on appetite, perhaps because the selected alginates do not produce sufficiently strong gels or because the alginates were not sufficiently hydrated when consumed. Therefore, the objective of the study was to test effects on appetite of a strongly gelling and fully hydrated alginate in an acceptable, low-viscosity drink formulation. In a balanced order crossover design, 23 volunteers consumed a meal replacement drink containing protein and calcium and either 0 (control), 0.6, or 0.8% of a specific high-guluronate alginate. Appetite (six self-report scales) was measured for 5 h postconsumption. Relevant physicochemical properties of the drinks were measured, i.e., product viscosity and strength of gel formed under simulated gastric conditions. Hunger was robustly reduced (20-30% lower area under the curve) with 0.8% alginate (P < 0.001, analysis of covariance), an effect consistent across all appetite scales. Most effects were also significant with 0.6% alginate, and a clear dose-response observed. Gastric gel strength was 1.8 and 3.8 N for the 0.6 and 0.8% alginate drinks, respectively, while product viscosity was acceptable (<0.5 Pa.s at 10 s(-1)). We conclude that strongly gastric-gelling alginates at relatively low concentrations in a low-viscosity drink formulation produced a robust reduction in hunger responses. This and other related studies indicate that the specific alginate source and product matrix critically impacts upon apparent efficacy.
But, the following study does not conclude that alginate is effective.
Odunsi ST, Vazquez-Roque MI, Camilleri M, et al. Effect of alginate on satiation, appetite, gastric function, and selected gut satiety hormones in overweight and obesity. Obesity (Silver Spring) 2010;18(8):1579-84. Effect of alginate on satiation, appetite, gastric... [Obesity (Silver Spring). 2010] - PubMed result
Lack of control of food intake, excess size, and frequency of meals are critical to the development of obesity. The stomach signals satiation postprandially and may play an important role in control of calorie intake. Sodium alginate (based on brown seaweed Laminaria digitata) is currently marketed as a weight loss supplement, but its effects on gastric motor functions and satiation are unknown. We evaluated effects of 10 days treatment with alginate or placebo on gastric functions, satiation, appetite, and gut hormones associated with satiety in overweight or obese adults. We conducted a randomized, 1:1, placebo-controlled, allocation-concealed study in 48 overweight or obese participants with excluded psychiatric comorbidity and binge eating disorder. All underwent measurements of gastric emptying (GE), fasting, and postprandial gastric volumes (GVs), postprandial satiation, calorie intake at a free choice meal and selected gut hormones after 1 week of alginate (three capsules vs. matching placebo per day, ingested 30 min before the main meal). Six capsules were ingested with water 30 min before the GE, GV, and satiation tests on days 8-10. There were no treatment group effects on GE or volumes, gut hormones (ghrelin, cholecystokinin (CCK), glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1), peptide YY (PYY)), satiation, total and macronutrient calorie intake at a free choice meal. There was no difference detected in results between obese and overweight patients. Alginate treatment for a period of 10 days showed no effect on gastric motor functions, satiation, appetite, or gut hormones. These results question the use of short-term alginate treatment for weight loss.
[The very company making the product EMPLOYS the authors. It sounds very similar to the product by Gelesis - Gelesis | About Gelesis .]
Experimental Drink Could Help Dieters Feel Full
Medical News: Experimental Drink Could Help Dieters Feel Full - in Primary Care, Obesity from MedPage Today
With the growing epidemic of obesity, Dutch researchers may have come up with a way for people to stick to their diets and lose weight -- an experimental meal replacement drink that seems to reduce hunger pangs and help dieters feel full longer.
A study conducted among 23 volunteers found that the drink reduced their hunger by as much as 30%, five hours (P< 0.001) after drinking it, reported Harry Peters, a manager-scientist of Unilever Research & Development in Vlaardingen, the Netherlands, and colleagues.
The secret ingredient: a strongly gelling dietary fiber called alginate.
"The drink was designed in such a way that it only gels under gastric conditions and not in the product before consumption," Peters and co-authors explained online in the journalObesity. They theorized that a drink of this kind "would dose-dependently decrease hunger responses at relatively low alginate levels."
A drink containing the gelling fiber that was palatable and able to delay the return of hunger could potentially increase consumer satisfaction with weight control programs and low-calorie food products, and thus encourage long-term compliance, the Dutch team suggested.
"Satiety feelings on a meal-to-meal basis are partly determined by gastrointestinal (GI) stimuli," they wrote. "One way to increase satiety is by formation of gels within the stomach. However, the viscosity of drinks needs to be high to increase satiety, and this may reduce consumer acceptance for many (e.g., fluid) types of products."
But producing a palatable drink based on post-consumption gelatin stimulated by gastric conditions might therefore be a preferred option, they suggested.
So they whipped up an experimental low-viscosity breakfast drink -- a prototype ready-to-drink chocolate-flavored meal replacement shake containing 190 calories in 325 ml (around 10 oz) -- using two concentrations of alginate (0.6% and 0.8%) designed to turn into a satiating gel only after it was consumed. Controls consumed the shake without added alginate.
A group of healthy volunteers were recruited from around the Unilever research site in Vlaardingen; 23 completed the study.
The volunteers (mean age around 53) consumed the drink containing various levels of alginate in place of a meal and reported their levels of hunger and fullness over the next five hours.
Volunteers who had the highest level of alginate in their drinks reported less hunger than the control group, with both "hunger" and "fullness" reduced robustly (20% and 34% lower area under the curve, respectively) with 0.8% alginate (both P<0.001, analysis of covariance). This effect was consistent across all six appetite scales used, Peters and co-authors wrote.
Most effects were also significant with 0.6% alginate, and a clear dose-response was observed.
"Although self-reported decreases in hunger are robustly reported in this study, further studies are needed to establish its implications for food intake, compliance to weight-loss programs, and long-term effects on weight loss or weight maintenance," Peters and colleagues concluded.
Peters HP, Koppert RJ, Boers HM, et al. Dose-Dependent Suppression of Hunger by a Specific Alginate in a Low-Viscosity Drink Formulation. Obesity (Silver Spring). Dose-Dependent Suppression of Hunger by a Specific... [Obesity (Silver Spring). 2011] - PubMed result
Addition of specific types of alginates to drinks can enhance postmeal suppression of hunger, by forming strong gastric gels in the presence of calcium. However, some recent studies have not demonstrated an effect of alginate/calcium on appetite, perhaps because the selected alginates do not produce sufficiently strong gels or because the alginates were not sufficiently hydrated when consumed. Therefore, the objective of the study was to test effects on appetite of a strongly gelling and fully hydrated alginate in an acceptable, low-viscosity drink formulation. In a balanced order crossover design, 23 volunteers consumed a meal replacement drink containing protein and calcium and either 0 (control), 0.6, or 0.8% of a specific high-guluronate alginate. Appetite (six self-report scales) was measured for 5 h postconsumption. Relevant physicochemical properties of the drinks were measured, i.e., product viscosity and strength of gel formed under simulated gastric conditions. Hunger was robustly reduced (20-30% lower area under the curve) with 0.8% alginate (P < 0.001, analysis of covariance), an effect consistent across all appetite scales. Most effects were also significant with 0.6% alginate, and a clear dose-response observed. Gastric gel strength was 1.8 and 3.8 N for the 0.6 and 0.8% alginate drinks, respectively, while product viscosity was acceptable (<0.5 Pa.s at 10 s(-1)). We conclude that strongly gastric-gelling alginates at relatively low concentrations in a low-viscosity drink formulation produced a robust reduction in hunger responses. This and other related studies indicate that the specific alginate source and product matrix critically impacts upon apparent efficacy.
But, the following study does not conclude that alginate is effective.
Odunsi ST, Vazquez-Roque MI, Camilleri M, et al. Effect of alginate on satiation, appetite, gastric function, and selected gut satiety hormones in overweight and obesity. Obesity (Silver Spring) 2010;18(8):1579-84. Effect of alginate on satiation, appetite, gastric... [Obesity (Silver Spring). 2010] - PubMed result
Lack of control of food intake, excess size, and frequency of meals are critical to the development of obesity. The stomach signals satiation postprandially and may play an important role in control of calorie intake. Sodium alginate (based on brown seaweed Laminaria digitata) is currently marketed as a weight loss supplement, but its effects on gastric motor functions and satiation are unknown. We evaluated effects of 10 days treatment with alginate or placebo on gastric functions, satiation, appetite, and gut hormones associated with satiety in overweight or obese adults. We conducted a randomized, 1:1, placebo-controlled, allocation-concealed study in 48 overweight or obese participants with excluded psychiatric comorbidity and binge eating disorder. All underwent measurements of gastric emptying (GE), fasting, and postprandial gastric volumes (GVs), postprandial satiation, calorie intake at a free choice meal and selected gut hormones after 1 week of alginate (three capsules vs. matching placebo per day, ingested 30 min before the main meal). Six capsules were ingested with water 30 min before the GE, GV, and satiation tests on days 8-10. There were no treatment group effects on GE or volumes, gut hormones (ghrelin, cholecystokinin (CCK), glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1), peptide YY (PYY)), satiation, total and macronutrient calorie intake at a free choice meal. There was no difference detected in results between obese and overweight patients. Alginate treatment for a period of 10 days showed no effect on gastric motor functions, satiation, appetite, or gut hormones. These results question the use of short-term alginate treatment for weight loss.
Last edited: