The comparisons have come hard and fast, at least since 2015. Trump is like Silvio Berlusconi, like Adolf Hitler, like Boris Johnson. A 2018 film called “The Trump Prophecy” took the evangelical route, comparing Trump to Cyrus the Great, the 6th century BC Persian monarch chosen by God to free Jewish captives in Babylon.
But maybe it’s time to stop searching for the exact analogy for Trump, be he Cyrus or Boris, Adolf or a Silvio. What demands analysis is less the arrogant 73-year-old mediocrity in the Oval Office, but the worshipful attitude so many Americans have toward him.
A lot of nut jobs have peddled lies to Americans before, and even styled themselves as messianic. But at no time in history have so
many Americans been drawn to what’s looking increasingly like a cult. I don’t use the term recklessly.
When Steven Hassan, an expert in cults and an ex-Moonie (as in the Unification Church, founded by a Korean businessman, the Rev. Sun Myung Moon), published “The Cult of Trump” last spring, some reviewers objected to his use of the cult framework as incendiary and not all that useful.
...
As 2019 drew to a close, my doubts about Trumpism as a cult dissolved. And I’m not alone.
Republican lawyer George Conway reportedly described his wife, Trump’s presidential counselor Kellyanne Conway, as a member of a cult. Former GOP strategist John Weaver has used the term. https://nam04.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnn.com%2Fvideos%2Fmedia%2F2019%2F11%2F10%2Fscaramucci-likens-trump-to-support-cult-fox-news-vpx.cnn&data=02%7C01%7CSusan.Brenneman%40latimes.com%7C2a63fc1a4c824dff539a08d794add9b3%7Ca42080b34dd948b4bf44d70d3bbaf5d2%7C0%7C0%7C637141346712068852&sdata=kb88tz7zY%2BEXU5bW5NMiEtCiAwGbUFGoUGRc4%2Bs%2BoVg%3D&reserved=0 (Anthony Scaramucci), Trump’s onetime communications director, concurs. https://nam04.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnn.com%2Fvideos%2Fbusiness%2F2019%2F11%2F17%2Fdan-rather-mcconnell-is-part-of-the-trump-cult&data=02%7C01%7CSusan.Brenneman%40latimes.com%7C2a63fc1a4c824dff539a08d794add9b3%7Ca42080b34dd948b4bf44d70d3bbaf5d2%7C0%7C0%7C637141346712078842&sdata=mnp%2FW5wA%2B7J3iJeLY8oIJunWYLBMaiI8MR%2BGF3B9Wtc%3D&reserved=0, conservative political scientist
Norman Ornstein, science journalist
Steve Silberman, pastor
John Pavlovitz and academic and journalist
Jared Yates Sexton.
What the cult diagnosis may lack in scholarly rigor, it makes up for in explanatory power. When polled, far too many Republicans come across as having abandoned their commitment to libertarianism, family values or simple logic in favor of Trump worship. They’re lost to paranoia and factually unmoored talking points, just the way Hassan was lost to Sun Myung Moon.
It can be heartbreaking when loved ones succumb to Trumpism. (It’s a double whammy when your grief is dismissed as liberal tears.) A true believer undergoes a “radical personal change,” as Hassan puts it. The person you once knew seems somehow ... not there.
Journalists
Luke O’Neil and
Edwin Lyngar, as well as Jen Senko in “
The Brainwashing of My Dad,” have compiled stories of Americans who have gone over. O’Neil
summarized the transformation this way: “A loved one … sat down in front of Fox News, found some kind of deep, addictive comfort in the anger and paranoia, and became a different person.”
Sounds about right.
To see Trumpism as a cult is not to refuse to engage with its effects, the crimes committed in its name or the way it has awakened and emboldened the cruelest and most destructive beliefs and practices in the American playbook. Instead, the cult framework should
relieve the pressure many of us feel to call Trumpites back to themselves, to keep arguing with them. They are stuck in a bad relationship with a controlling figure.
Understanding Trump is a fool’s errand. He’s sui generis, and far too erratic and finally insubstantial to reward close attention. Trump zealots are another matter. They are part of the tradition of radical converts in American history who elected to forfeit their authentic personalities and principles rather than refine or strengthen them. We need to stay focused on how so many Americans came to this pass and took this destructive course. The Trump cult will define American politics for decades to come, even after its dear leader is gone.