See that’s the funny thing about it and individuality. When I do meadows row I get a nasty pump and contraction and can just feel the tension throughout the whole motion. Now with like a lat pulldown not so much. Even single arm Barbell or dB Row I don’t feel like quite like I do with the meadows row. Plus, I think we’re so used to this “progressive overload” theory which yes is true and works very well but I myself with a new exercise start way to heavy trying to compare it to another motion or use a weight I THINK I should be using before I ever even get it down pat. Front squats for instance the other day I’ve never done before. It was a very sloppy exercise for me and I realized that and just stuck with 135 and even doing so I still feel like I wasn’t doing it right. I could have gone heavier. For sure. But, wouldn’t have made any difference and I would have needed up dropping the bar or hurting myself.
Dude I’m totally with you on a new exercise and starting too heavy when really it’s about learning how to maximize contraction with it at first then add weight. Sometimes I’ll start with Meadows’ example weights and progressions and remember very quickly he is a pro heavyweight haha.
We all embrace different exercises, just goes to show how different we all are in terms of body mechanics and mentally. I believe we need to focus on and get better with the exercises we suck at rather than sticking with the ones we love. I figure there is probably a good reason why I suck at a certain movement. You mention front squats and that is a great example for me as well. My shoulders are not flexible enough to really get that proper grip with elbows up high. Or maybe I just need to get used to it. Or just cross my hands over my shoulders and hold the bar up that way. Either way I’ve got to get more front squats in my life.